A good 1-on-1 meeting can change everything. It’s a rare chance to step away from the daily grind and have a meaningful conversation that builds trust and strengthens the working relationship. But when these meetings feel rushed or repetitive, their value quickly disappears.
Kim Scott, author of Radical Candor, put it best:
"The purpose of a one-on-one meeting is to listen and clarify. To understand what direction each person working for you wants to head in, and what is blocking them."
These conversations give managers a window into what their team members need to succeed if they’re willing to listen.
Despite the pressure to stay on top of deadlines and deliverables, carving out time for regular 1-on-1s is one of the smartest investments a leader can make. These meetings create space for real conversations that build connection and reveal concerns before they turn into larger problems.
When managers take the time to engage in meaningful dialogue, it reinforces trust and shows employees they’re more than a name on a task list. These check-ins can also clarify priorities and uncover ways to support personal development.
Beyond performance metrics, 1-on-1s offer a glimpse into how someone is actually doing—their mindset, their challenges, and the questions they might not voice in a team setting. In fast-moving environments, that kind of insight can be hard to access any other way.
Even well-intentioned managers can fall into habits that make 1-on-1 meetings feel stale or ineffective. Without structure and purpose, these conversations can easily drift off course. Or worse, they may start to feel like a waste of time. Recognizing the most common missteps is the first step toward making the most of this time together.
Few things send a stronger message than a manager consistently canceling 1-on-1s. It tells employees their time isn’t valuable and their concerns can wait. Over time, this erodes trust and discourages open communication. While emergencies happen, treating these meetings as non-negotiable helps reinforce their importance and keeps the relationship on steady ground.
When a 1-on-1 meeting turns into a status report, its potential is lost. Project updates have their place, but they shouldn’t dominate the conversation. If every meeting is focused on tasks and deadlines, there’s little room for reflection, feedback, or future planning.
Employees benefit most when these meetings include space to talk about career goals, roadblocks, and what kind of support would help them succeed. A few minutes on project updates is fine, but the heart of the conversation should center on growth and connection.
Showing up without a plan sends the message that the meeting isn’t a priority. When managers wing it, conversations tend to meander or stay surface-level, leaving both sides unsure of what was accomplished. Preparation doesn’t need to be time-consuming, but it should be intentional.
Reviewing notes from the previous meeting, setting a loose agenda, and coming in with a few thoughtful questions can go a long way. It shows respect for the employee’s time and helps ensure the conversation stays focused and meaningful.
Few things kill momentum like inaction. If issues raised in a 1-on-1 go unresolved or feedback is ignored, trust begins to erode. Employees start to feel unheard, and future conversations may become less candid or less frequent.
Even small steps, such as circling back on a question or confirming a timeline, can demonstrate accountability and keep progress moving. Following up shows that what’s discussed in these meetings actually matters.
Creating a consistent structure for 1-on-1 meetings helps make them more intentional, more effective, and easier to maintain over time. The best meetings aren’t overplanned, but they do have a rhythm that keeps both people engaged and focused.
A strong 1-on-1 isn’t about checking boxes; it’s about building a relationship. That begins with a clear understanding of what the meeting is for, and what it isn’t.
Irregular or unpredictable meetings lose momentum. Whether it’s weekly, biweekly, or monthly, having a reliable schedule sets expectations and makes space for issues to surface before they escalate. Keeping the same day and time also reduces cancellations and supports follow-through.
Instead of coming in with separate lists (or no list at all), use a shared document where both the manager and employee can add topics ahead of time. This gives the meeting a sense of shared ownership and encourages active participation. Revisiting the agenda regularly also helps track progress and keep conversations focused.
Good 1-on-1s aren’t just status updates. They’re opportunities to understand how a person is doing, not just what they’re doing. You might ask:
These types of questions open the door to deeper insights and more meaningful conversations.
A productive 1-on-1 should feel collaborative. If one person does all the talking, the meeting becomes a missed opportunity. Managers should encourage honest feedback about leadership, team dynamics, and broader concerns.
Creating space for the employee to lead parts of the conversation can also build confidence and trust. When people feel heard and supported, they’re more likely to stay engaged and bring their best to the work.
The most effective meetings are the ones that feel personal, intentional, and grounded in real conversation. These moments don’t need to be formal to be impactful, but they do need to be thoughtful.
Taking a few minutes to ask how someone is doing—outside of work—can set a more human tone. It doesn’t need to be overly personal, but checking in about life outside deadlines helps build rapport. This is especially valuable if you’re managing remote or hybrid employees who may feel disconnected.
Use part of the meeting to look beyond immediate tasks. Revisit long-term goals, explore skill-building opportunities, or ask what kind of support would be most helpful right now. Try framing this as a conversation about progress rather than performance. That shift in tone can make employees feel more supported and less evaluated.
Writing down key takeaways shows you’re listening and helps ensure that action items don’t fall through the cracks. Consider using a shared document or follow-up email to confirm next steps. This creates accountability and reinforces the idea that these meetings lead to real outcomes, not just conversation.
Consistent and effective 1-on-1 meetings don’t just happen. They grow out of strong leadership, intentional communication, and a commitment to supporting others. When managers approach these conversations with purpose, they create space for trust to grow and for people to feel seen and heard.
Whether you're leading a small team or managing across departments, focusing on the quality of your 1-on-1s can lead to stronger engagement, better collaboration, and a healthier workplace culture overall.
When you partner with Ulliance, our Life Advisor Consultants are always just a phone call away to teach ways to enhance your work/life balance and increase your happiness. The Ulliance Life Advisor Employee Assistance Program can help employees and employers come closer to a state of total well-being.
Investing in the right EAP or Wellness Program to support your employees will help them and help you. Visit https://ulliance.com/ or call 866-648-8326.
The Ulliance Employee Assistance Program can address the
following issues:
• Stress about work or job performance
• Crisis in the workplace
• Conflict resolution at work or in one’s personal life
• Marital or relationship problems
• Child or elder care concerns
• Financial worries
• Mental health problems
• Alcohol/substance abuse
• Grief
• Interpersonal conflicts
• AND MORE!
References:
7 Things to Know About 1:1 Meetings That Make You a Better Manager; Kim Scott https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/7-things-know-11-meetings-make-you-better-manager-kim-scott
A Guide to 1:1 Meetings: Benefits, Tips & Agenda Templates; Small Improvements https://www.small-improvements.com/resources/1-on-1-meetings
Meet Like A Boss — The 411 On 1:1s 2 | 9; Radical Candorhttps://www.radicalcandor.com/podcast/s2-e9-meet-like-a-boss-the-411-on-one-on-ones/
Top 6 Mistakes Managers Make During 1-on-1 Meetings; PeopleHum https://www.peoplehum.com/blog/top-6-mistakes-managers-make-during-1-on-1-meetings